When it comes to drumming, there are two primary options to consider: acoustic drum sets and electric drum sets. Both have their own distinct advantages that cater to the different needs and preferences of drummers. In this article, we will be comparing the benefits of acoustic and electric drums - targeting drummers who are seeking guidance in selecting the right instrument for their musical journey.
Acoustic Drum Sets
Genuine Sound
One of the major benefits of acoustic drum sets is their natural and authentic sound. The deep, organic tones produced by the drums and cymbals create a unique and impactful experience for both the player and the audience. Obviously this depends on the heads and also the tuning of the drums has been done correctly too.
Wide Range of Dynamics
Acoustic drums offer a broad dynamic range, allowing drummers to express themselves with varying levels of volume and intensity. This versatility is particularly important in genres such as jazz and rock.
Physical Response
Playing on an acoustic drum set provides a physical response that helps drummers develop a better sense of timing, control, and technique. The tactile experience of striking a real drumhead and feeling the vibrations adds an additional layer of connection and expression. Even being able to hit the drum in a slightly different place to get more overtones for example if needed. The same can be said for the feel of the hihat and the cymbals.
Electric Drum Sets
Flexibility
Electric drum sets offer a vast range of sounds and tones that can be customized to fit various musical styles and genres. Drummers can experiment with different drum samples, add effects, and even play non-percussive sounds.
Volume Management
One of the key advantages of electric drum sets is the ability to control the volume. With the option to use headphones or adjust the output level, drummers can practice and perform at any time of the day without disturbing others. This is really useful if you're in a flat for example where you wouldn't be able to use an acoustic kit because of neighbours.
Recording and Integration
Electric drum sets can easily be connected to recording software and MIDI devices, allowing drummers to record their performances, trigger virtual instruments, and integrate with other digital music production tools.
Technology
I guess the other thing to mention here is that technology is always improving and with that in mind electronic drum sets are always getting better. This can also lead to an electric you bought six months ago depreciating in value pretty quickly. (This happened to me!). Behind acoustic drums means that they hold their value pretty much throughout - also if you've bought a good kit it could go for a vintage price in a few years!
In summary, both acoustic and electric drum sets have their own unique advantages. Acoustic drum sets excel in providing an authentic sound, wide dynamic range, and physical response, while electric drum sets offer flexibility, volume management, and seamless integration with digital tools.
The choice ultimately depends on the drummer's musical preferences, performance requirements, and the environment in which they will be playing. Whether it's the raw power of acoustic drums or the versatility of electric drums, both options can help drummers unleash their creativity and achieve their musical goals. I know which one I prefer - how about you? Comment below 👇🏻
ABOUT MARK
Mark is an online session drummer and producer based in Reading UK providing remotely recorded drums to clients all over the world.
His main focus on the drums is to always serve the song and listen to what is being played by the other instruments in the band. Be aware of the song and how it develops.
Find out more information here:
Download FREE Drum Stem packs here: